Rittenhouse Inn Review | Bayfield, Wisconsin

Rittenhouse Inn
The historic 1890 Rittenhouse Inn sits on a hill above downtown Bayfield, Wisconsin

Dining and Lodging at the Rittenhouse Inn
Bayfield, WI

Rittenhouse Inn Lobby
The lobby of the Rittenhouse Inn with its 2 story Christmas Tree.

Few visitors to Bayfield escape noticing the historic Rittenhouse Inn on the main Highway 13 road into downtown (Rittenhouse Avenue). Perched high on the hill about five blocks up from the harbor, its size, beauty and Victorian architecture evokes “wows” and more erudite exclamations. In addition to being Bayfield’s only 4 star hotel, it is also known for its fine cusine. It has been on our “bucket list” to spend a night or two there for some time.

The opportunity to make good on our pledge came on a Thanksgiving weekend in 2015 with Jo’s sister Donna and her husband Dan. Previously we had done Thanksgiving weekends at four other historic hotels stretching along the Great River Road Scenic Drive from Galena, Illinois to Stillwater, Minnesota. The Rittenhouse Inn Thanksgiving Weekend will be the first of perhaps several historic hotel Thanksgivings we’ll have along the Lake Superior Circle Drive.

Rittenhouse Inn Review

Rittenhouse Inn Dining
Thanksgiving Menu at the Rittenhouse Inn Bayfield, WI

The dinner itself was fantastic. The historic hotels we’ve previously stayed at offered a Thanksgiving Buffet. The Rittenhouse Inn meal was a five course extravaganza with a choice of two soups, two salads, four specialty entrees, and four desserts plus a Sorbet before the Entree. (See pictures and more details at our Rittenshouse Inn Dining Review here).

Staying overnight at the Rittenhouse was also a bit different than we had experienced at other historic inns. The Rittenhouse, being a mansion B&B versus a larger hotel, was more intimate and held truer to the theme of “stepping back in time” to staying at a Victorian Inn. The only piece of “modern technology” in the rooms were a small clock radio. No TV, no microwave, no fridge, no phone, no desk for our laptop, and no bar or lounge in the facility (but craft beers and bottles of wine were available from the kitchen or wait staff to take back to your room.) We were pleased to discover there was one concession to the 21st century – a strong wireless Internet connection. (See our slide show tour of Rittenhouse Inn Rooms here).

Rittenhouse Inn Sitting Room
Jo and Donna relaxing in the second floor sitting room of the Rittenhouse Inn

Great food, unique and comfortable lodging, and great service made for a memorable and romantic weekend.



Rittenhouse Inn
Bayfield Holiday Activities
Bayfield Area Winter Events


Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.